logo

Bibliometric Analysis of the “Indian Journal of Marketing” from 2010-2014



Abstract :

In this electronic era there is awareness of the advantages of quantitative evaluation. The science is concerned that bibliometric indicators are must for evaluation of document, file or any text. In this paper, I will begin with a brief history of bibliometrics, to trace its origins and define its role in the evaluation of articles. We shall present a variety of bibliometric indicators, noting their uses and their limitations. The aim of this study is to highlight both the strengths and weaknesses of bibliometric indicators.

Bibliometrics is a tool by which the state of science and technology can be observed through the overall production of literature. Bibliometrics can be an aid to decision-making and research management. Bibliometric indicators are practical tools which can be used in combination with other indicators. Each indicator has its advantages and its limitations and care must be taken not to consider them as “absolute” indices.

KEYWORDS:

Bibliometric, Citation Analysis, Authorship, Citation

Intoduction:

The Bibliometric is a research method mostly used in library and information science and is a quantitative study of various aspects of literature on a topic. It is used to identify the pattern of publication, authorship and the secondary journal coverage to gain insight into the dynamics of growth of knowledge in the areas under the consideration. Pritchard coined a new term “bibliometrics” in 1969. Bibliometrics was defined as the application of mathematical and statistical methods to books and journal articles. Bibliometrics has a specific measurements and indicators and purpose is to measure the output of scientific and technological research through data.

Bibliometric techniques have evolved over time and are continuing to do so the counting of papers with attribution by geographical area, by institution and by author. The counting of citations, to measure the impact of published work on the scientific community; the counting of co-citations; the number of times that two papers are cited together in a single paper etc. All these techniques combine to give more detailed and more effective measurements and the results are presented in various forms, like that mapping, in order to depict the relationships between participants and expand the means for analysis of documents. Dr. S.R. Ranganathan, library science scientist coined the term “librametry” in 1948. It is historically appeared first and was intended to streamline the services of librarianship. Bibliometrics is equivalent to Ranganathan’s librametrics; the Russian concept scientometrics; infometrics; webometrics and subdisciplines like econometrics; psychometrics; sociometrics; biometrics; technometrics; chemometrics; and climetrics; where mathematics and statistics are applied to study and solve problems in their respective fields. Scientometrics is used for the application of quantitative methods to the history of science and overlaps with bibliometrics to a considerable extent.

DEFINITION:

Some definitions of bibliometrics are given below:

    - Pritchard says that “all studies which seek to quantify processes of written communication”.

    - Fairthorne says that “the quantitative treatment of the properties of recorded discourse and
      behavior pertaining to it”.

THE NEED TO EVALUATE RESEARCH

The periodicals are the indicators of literature growth in the field of knowledge and it is emerge as the main trace for transmit knowledge. Because of to the escalating cost of the periodicals and lack of adequate library budgets the selection of any particular periodical for a library should be done more carefully. That’s why the library authorities are forced to reduce the number of periodical subscriptions. Bibliometric analysis has huge applications in the LIS filed in identifying the research trends in the subject, core journals, etc. so that the frame new subscription policies develop for day before. These studies will be helpful for librarians to plan a better collection development in their library.

BIBLIOMETRIC DATABASES:

The different types of databases are mentioned below. The source for bibliometrics is always a database.

    1. Chemical Abstracts: It is special database of physics and chemistry database and it is produced by an American company, Chemical Abstracts Services, for the American Chemical Society.
    2. Compendex: It is a special database of engineering and technology database. It is produced by an American company, Engineering Information.
    3. Embase: It is a special database of medical sciences database. It is produced by a Dutch company,Excerpta Medica.
    4. Inspec: It is a special database physical sciences database. It is produced by the Institute of Electrical Engineers in the United Kingdom.
    5. Pascal: It is a general database covering several fields. It is produced by the Institute for Scientificand Technical Information (INIST) at France’s National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS),
    6. Science Citation Index: It is a multidisciplinary database. It is produced by a US concern, the Institute for Information Science.

These databases are usually available online and/or on CD-ROM. Each database has its own content and entry criteria. All users of bibliometric indicators must therefore begin by choosing the databases best suited to their particular needs; to do so, they must first analysis the strengths, and limitations of the various databases of bibliometric. Bibliometric analysis uses numerous parameters, such as scientific literature (articles, etc.), co-authorship, patents, citations, co-citations and co-words and these parameters are indirect measures of articles.

Journal “INDIAN JOURNAL OF MARKETING”:

The Journal “INDIAN JOURNAL OF MARKETING” (ISSN 0973-8703) is a double blind peer reviewed refereed monthly journal, it was started in 1968. It is the very oldest and the only monthly journal of Marketing in the India. It is an authentic for research publication dealing with Marketing; Advertising; Consumer Behaviour; Sales Management; Advertising & Promotion Management; Business Education; Business Information Systems (MIS); Business Law; Communication; Direct Marketing; Global Business; Health Care Administration; Marketing Research; Marketing Theory & Applications; Office Administration/Management; Organizational Development; Production/Operations; Public Administration; Retailing; Sales/Selling; Services; Tourism, Hospitality and Leisure; and Industrial Organization.

The Journal “Indian Journal of Marketing” is disseminating knowledge. It is ensures good practice of professional marketing. It is encouraging research and thinking and attempts to contribute to a better perception of marketing theories and its framework and resources and structures and systems and processes and performance of organizations because its focal point is on research and reflections relevant to academicians, research scholar and practicing managers.

NEED FOR THE STUDY

The Periodicals are the indicators of literature growth in any field of the knowledge. They emerge as the main channel for transmitting knowledge. Because of the escalating cost of the periodicals and lack of decent library budgets, the selection of any journal for a library should be done properly. Now a day the Library authorities are forced to reduce the number of journal subscriptions. Bibliometric analysis has relevance in library and information science in determine research trends, core journals, etc., and so that framing subscription policies for tomorrow. This study will be helpful for librarians for the collection development for their library.

OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

The objective of the present study has been analyzing the objectives aspects.

    - To analysis of articles published from 2010-2014 only for the “Indian Journal of Marketing”

    - To identify the number of contributions in published articles.

    - To determine the year-wise distribution of articles in that particular journal only.

    - To study the authorship pattern

    - To study the subject coverage of articles in that journal.

    - To study the length of articles of particular journal.

METHODOLOGY

The methodology applied in the present study is bibliometric analysis that is used to study in detail the bibliographic features of the particular journal articles and citation analysis of the references at the end of each article published in “Indian Journal of Marketing” from 2010-2014. For this the relevant data are collected and recorded in separate file. Then they are tabulated and analysed for making observations for the bibliometric research study.

DATA ANALYSIS
The analysis was done in two parts

    1) Analysis of articles and 2) Analysis of citations.

  • Article Analysis
    • All the details such as author(s), title, year of publication and pagination etc., of all articles published from 2010 to 2014 were recorded for the following analysis.

    • Number of Articles:
    • A total number of 390 articles published during the period 2010-2014 and has been recorded for the present study.

      Year

      Vol.

      No. of Issues

      No. of Articles

      %age

      2010

      40

      12

      91

      23.34

      2011

      41

      12

      93

      23.85

      2012

      42

      12

      81

      20.76

      2013

      43

      12

      70

      17.94

      2014

      44

      12

      55

      14.11

      Total

      60

      390

      100.00


      Table-1 Year-wise Distribution of Articles

      The table-1 shows the maximum number of articles published in 2011 (93) and minimum in 2014 (55) articles. The journal publishes on an average of 78 articles per year.

    • Subject Distribution of Articles:

    • Subject

      No.of Articles

      %age

      Consumer Behavior

      140

      35.90

      Branding

      105

      26.92

      Online Marketing

      45

      11.53

      Retailing

      30

      7.70

      Rural Marketing

      25

      6.41

      Marketing Strategies

      20

      5.12

      Others

      25

      6.42

      Total

      390

      100.00

      Table-2 Subject Distribution of Articles

      Chart- 1

      Table 2 and chart-1 above shows that a majority of a contributions appeared under Consumer Behavior 140 (35.90%) and on branding shows 105 (26.92%). After that position is taken by Online marketing 45 (11.53%), Retailing 30 (7.70%), Rural Marketing 25 (6.41%), Marketing Strategies 20 (5.12%), Other subjects of marketing 25 (6.42%).

    • Authorship Pattern:

    • Year

      No. of Authors

      Total

      1

      2

      3

      4

      2010

      40

      42

      7

      89

      2011

      45

      39

      5

      1

      90

      2012

      39

      35

      7

      81

      2013

      25

      41

      7

      1

      74

      2014

      11

      29

      12

      3

      55

      Total

      160

      186

      38

      5

      389

      %age

      41.14

      47.82

      9.76

      1.28

      100

      Table-3 Authorship pattern


      Chart- 2

      Table 3 and Chart-2 reveals the authorship pattern of the articles published during the period of this study. The largest number of articles had two authors 186 (47.82%). This is followed by single author 160 (41.14%), three authors 38 (9.76%) and four authors with 5 (1.28%) of the total articles.

    • Year-wise Authorship Pattern:

    • Authorship

      Year

      Total

      %age

      2010

      2011

      2012

      2013

      2014

      Single

      40

      45

      39

      25

      11

      160

      41.13

      Joint

      49

      46

      40

      49

      45

      229

      58.87

      Total

      89

      91

      79

      74

      56

      389

      100.00

      Table-4 Year-wise Authorship pattern

      The above table-4 shows that out of 390 articles single authors contributed 160 (41.13%) while the rest 229 (58.57%) articles were contributed by joint authors.

    • Institution-wise Contribution:

    • Name of Institute

      No. of Articles

      %age

      Universities

      93

      33.34

      Colleges

      63

      22.58

      Business School

      84

      30.11s

      Research Institute

      27

      9.67

      Companies

      12

      4.30

      Total

      279

      100.00



      Chart- 3

      A majority of the articles 93 (33.34%) were contributed by Universities. This is followed by Business school with 84 (30.11%) and colleges 63 (22.58%) articles and research institute 27 (9.67%). The remaining 12 (4.30%) articles were contributed by Companies.

    • Length of Articles:

    • Authorship

      Year

      Total

      %age

      2010

      2011

      2012

      2013

      2014

      5-10

      18

      25

      23

      30

      28

      124

      31.79

      11-15

      25

      30

      26

      32

      28

      141

      36.15

      16-20

      20

      35

      29

      21

      20

      125

      32.06

      Total

      63

      80

      78

      83

      76

      390

      100.00


      Table-6 Length of Articles

      Above table shows that the majority articles 141 (36.15%) have the length of 11-15 pages followed by 125 (32.06%) articles with the 16-20 pages and remaining 124 (31.79%) articles with (5-10) page.

  • Citation Analysis:
    • In the citation analysis the references provided by the authors at the end of their article and it are basis of citation analysis method. The Citation traces a connection between two documents, in that the one which cites and another which is cited. The Citation analysis is one of the popular methods for the citation and it is applied to derive the following aspects:

    • Referencing Characteristics:
    • Articles with and without references are accounted as follows:

      Category

      No. of Articles

      %age

      Without reference

      390

      100.00

      Total

      390

      100.00

      Table-7 Articles and references

      All the articles have references 390 (100.00 %).

    • Forms of Documents Cited:
    • Distribution of various forms of cited documents are given in the following table. They include journals, books, reference books, dissertations, conference proceedings, seminars etc.

      Forms of Documents

      Total No. of Citations

      %age

      Journals

      275

      40.44

      Books

      80

      11.76

      Proceedings

      180

      26.47

      Websites

      145

      21.33

      Total

      680

      100.00


      Table-8 Forms of documents cited


      Chart- 4

      A maximum authors are preferred journals as the source of information for their research articles and that all are occupied the top position with the highest number of citations 275 (40.44%) of the total 680 citations followed that position is occupied by proceedings with 180 (26.47%) citations, 145 (21.33%) articles shows websites as a references and least 80 (1.76%) articles shows books citations.

Findings:

From the above research here author find some findings and which are as below:

  1. Here find that the researchers are now a day not writes much more article. The researchers are interested to upload their articles on internet as an open source.

  2. In this “Indian Journal of Marketing” maximum articles are shows in the Consumer Behavior subjects.
  3. From this study here find that the sharing base or joint author articles are very high compare to others.
  4. In the Institute-wise contributors the universities are maximum.
  5. In the length of articles the maximum articles are shows more than 11-15 pages.
  6. Mostly all the articles are shows high references.
  7. Maximum authors are used journals for the research articles and their research work also.

Conclusion

The journal “Indian Journal of Marketing” has a very long history of 47 years, from that this study examined for five (2010-2014). In this period the journal has tried to keep up its main aim of acting as communication of all users of management, marketing and research scholars and commerce students and faculties to update their subjective knowledge. This research study reveals that the highest articles have appeared in the area of consumer study and consumer behavior.

The bibliometric techniques are being used for a variety of purposes like determination of various indicators and evaluation of output for a research documents. The journal has published 390 articles during the period of this research study. The maximum numbers of contributions are joint authors. The study revealed that the highest contributions were from universities. Majority of the authors preferred journals as the source of information for the highest number of citations.

References:

  1. Gilani, Satya, Indian Journal of Marketing. New Delhi: Associated Management Consultatns (P)>. Ltd., 2010-2014.
  2. British Standard Institution. British Standards of Documentation Terms. London: BSI,1976.
  3. De Solla Price, D.J. Little Science, Big Science. New York: Columbia University,1934.
  4. Hawkins, D.T. “Unconventional uses of On-line Information Retrieval Systems: Online Bibliometric studies”. Journal of American Society of Information Sciences.
  5. Morales, M. “Information and its Importance” International forum for Information and Documentation 10 (1985):15-21.
  6. Ranganathan, S.R. “Library and its Scope” DRTC Annual Seminar 702 (1969):285-301.


*************************************************** 

Dr. Jagdishchandra P. Gondalia
Librarian
Shree Mahila Art & Commerce College, Junagadh


Indira Dodiya
Asst. Librarian
K.S.School of Business Management,
Gujarat University, Ahmedabad

Previous index next
Copyright © 2012 - 2024 KCG. All Rights Reserved.   |    Powered By : Knowledge Consortium of Gujarat
Home  |   Archive  |   Advisory Committee  |   Contact us